I agree completely with Software_Bob.
Strengths:Seems to render video alright.
Weaknesses:Very buggy, quirky install errors and procedures, inane tech support. Burning issues invalidate rest of programs.
Posted May 20, 2007 - I bought this program mainly for video editing in lieu of Adobe Premiere only because of the wealth of features. However, if the features don't work it defeats the purpose. I had a couple of minor glitches at install (and also was irritated with the constant registration of each module on 1st use?). It didn't like my ATI drivers and Roxio's solution was to reinstall everything including windows, when in fact, ATI had an easy fix on their website. If you've ever dealt with ATI tech support it really tells you a lot about Roxio's. My first task was to copy the install discs. The first disc took 1/2 hour to copy, the second about 4 minutes - a task that usually takes a minute or so on the same system with other burners. Roxio tried to blame the hardware which is not a problem for any other burning program and had no clue why there was even such a difference between the 2 copies. (Note: The hardware is neither outdated, obscure nor underpowered). Next, to test the music module, I recorded an internet stream of an album with 18 tracks (something I do often with Magix Audio Cleaning lab). It produced a .wav file of 1.8GB. I then went to the editing feature which would not open the .wav file giving an error message that the file was invalid? I couldn't open the file in Windows Media Player either. So, I tried my Magix program which indicated an information error in the file, but did open it and automatically fixed the problem and recognized all 18 tracks perfectly and ran in Media Player. I then tried it again in EMC9 and it did open, and I used the auto track recognition feature which marked 20 tracks (2 erroneously). Also, the quality of the recording was not as good as I usually get with Magix. The good news is that the video editing went smoother than anything else, but I haven't tried to burn to DVD yet. In essence, the program is useless in all respects if it can't burn discs properly which should be a no-brainer for this type of software. If the hardware/software meets or exceeds Roxio's own minimums without exceptions listed, then it is expected to work with that hardware/software. Roxio, like too many other software companies today want to blame everything except their pathetic programming and inadequate testing. Conclusion: I'm giving up on these "we do everything, but unfortunately we do it half-a**" programs and stick to ones that do one thing and do it well, and none will be from Roxio.
100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful , unhelpful, or inappropriate?
Comments - Post a comment