Nice feature set for this price range
Strengths:Clear and vivid day light shot; Nice optical zoom with image stabilization feature; Good price.
Weaknesses:No flash for still shot; Grainy low light shot; Short battery life; USB port hidden behind battery pack, has to remove battery and use DC power for data transfer.
Posted Aug 13, 2007 - I was deciding among three HDD-based camcorders at sub-$400 price level, namely JVC Everio GZMG130, Sony DCR-SR42, and this Panasonic SDR-H18. It appeared to me that JVC Everio series received a generally lower score than the rest two from various online reviews including those at CNET so it was out of my list first. CNET also gave Sony DCR-SR42 a relatively low review score. Besides, Sony DCR-SR42/62/82 seemed a bit overpriced for its feature set. So Panasonic SDR-H18 seemed to be the only choice to me for under $400. Well, I've not determined if this is a good purchase yet as this SDR-H18 certainly has lots of spaces for further improvement. So please allow me to focus on its weaknesses as some pre-warning:
1) Not-so-satisfactory low light shot performance: I remember some online sources mentioned that this H18 requires minimal 2 lux light density for low light shot and this was proven with my grainy videos in rooms with insufficient lights. Its stepup version, H200, has a better performance (min. 1 lux if I am not wrong) but is about $100 more expensive.
2) Awkward USB port design: This has been mentioned for several times by other reviewers. You have to remove the battery in order to use the USB port as well as the DC power socket. It also means you have to use the provided battery charger (cannot charge the battery while it is in the camcorder body). It appears to me that H18, H20 and H200 share the same form factor. This anyway does not pose a challenge to me so far, as I usually transform my video to my desktop; but I believe this will become an inconvenience for people on the go.
3) Short battery life: The provided 700 mAH only lasts for about 40 mins. Anyway I purchases an extra 3rd party 2100 mAH battery for around $20 with free shipping.
Overall this seems to be a good *budget* HDD-based camcorder for its sub-$400 price. But customers with not so tight budget may want to step up to its higher version H200, or Sony's DCR-SR200/300 series (NOT SR42/62 etc) and may find the added features well worth the extra money.
100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful , unhelpful, or inappropriate?
Comments - Post a comment