I took the plunge on a TiVo with this 40-hour unit ...
Strengths:Easy to record series. No tapes. One remote for everything. Inexpensive. Rewind/FastForward live TV.
Weaknesses:Remote control has SLOW response w/ cable converter box. "40 hours" isn't real capacity unless you want very low quality video. No dual-tuner recording.
Posted May 30, 2005 - I took the plunge on a TiVo with this 40-hour unit to see what all the hype was all about. A friend of mine told me how it is so convenient and that she can't live without TiVo now. Well, after testing this unit for a month, I cannot comprehend the hype behind TiVo. To start, the setup of TiVo is a bit complicated with all the cables and the series of screens to update the TiVo with the service. True, the unit conveniently records series and other favorites with ease and lets you rewind/fastforward live TV. However, allowing TiVo to record recommended shows comes at a risk of being interrupted while you're watching TV and get a popup asking you to cancel the recording. Additionally, TiVo thinks I have strange taste in TV shows as it records some of the oddest shows on television.
Recording quality when used in Best Quality is very nice. I don't see any degradation of the video and certainly no skipping. The RW/FF buttons are convenient though they sometimes have a delay when switching back to play.
Another part about TiVo I really am not fond is the remote control compatibility with my Comcast cable box. The TiVo remote can change channels on the cable box but the response time is around 2 seconds! That's a bit annoying because if you aren't sure what you button you pressed, you have to wait 2 seconds to read the cable box's response! That's not acceptable.
Connecting the TiVo to a wireless network is a mystery to me. I've read many FAQ's online & visited the TiVo.com support pages but nothing is getting me out of this mess. According to the settings menu on TiVo, the wireless network is detected but cannot send/receive any data to TiVo servers. I should also note that finding compatible TiVo network adapters also requires heavy research before going out to buy one. It is not the easiest thing.
For the convenience of an up-to-date VCR, TiVo is great. Great quality and very convenient. For all the other features TiVo boasts, such as picking recommendations, compatibility w/ cable boxes and networking, this unit lacks. So if you spend the money for a TiVo, expect using it as mostly a timed-recorder than anything else. Also beware of the annoying popups when it starts recording while you're watching TV.
88% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful , unhelpful, or inappropriate?