Blown highlights, barrel distortion, otherwise good resolution
Strengths:Body design/construction, LCD gorgeous/clear, very high resolution
Weaknesses:Autofocus system or metering does not read bright scenes and completely destroys them - white sky, pale vegetation;
Scroll wheel takes getting used to, barrel distortion is obvious
Posted 1 year ago - I love the feel and weight of this camera and the LCD. The pictures it takes correctly are very high resolution and nice colors. However, its autofocus or metering system messes up more often than normal. Taking pictures with white things in them or reflected light, or dark and light colors sometimes causes it to overexpose drastically.
What photos do turn out well (and if you can get it to focus on just the right object it will turn out, but it is extra work) are really good.
Other cameras I've had/tested are not like this. The Panasonic TZ4 didn't do this as bad in high contrast (it has "intelligent" vs. stupid autofocus). The Canon SD870 takes beautiful outdoor photos. Canon SD850 also overexposed bright shots at times.
To use this camera, be prepared to stick it on manual and drop the exposure .75 or so, or focus on something that clears up the picture, or it will be washed out and useless in certain situations.
I wrote Canon about this issue, wondering about a firmware update, and they imply it is normal behavior. Here are their comments:
CANON'S COMMENTS -
"The auto focus may not work well on the following types of subject:
Subjects with extremely low contrast to the surroundings Subjects mixing close and far objects Subjects with extremely bright objects at the center of the composition Subjects that are moving quickly Subjects captured using full zoom
To shoot these subjects, first aim the camera at an object at a similar distance, lock the focus and recompose the image with the desired subject, or use the manual focus.
One of the advantages of digital photography is that your results are instantaneous; there is no expense for film or processing, so you can take as many "practice" shots as you like and make corrections right away. We strongly suggest that you experiment with your camera until you are comfortable with its features, and that you prepare well in advance of any important event you wish to photograph. Unfortunately, due to many varying shooting/exposure conditions, we are unable to provide step-by-step instructions that will result in an exact combination of camera settings that will generate the results you desire."
93% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful , unhelpful, or inappropriate?