Strengths:Deep rich colors, bright screen, sharp image. Absolutely zero defective pixels. HDTV native resolution. Huge screen size for desk top - but perfect for games and DVDs. No ghosting. Great price!
Weaknesses:Confusing user interface (buttons and OSD) for making adjustments. Screen too bright out of the box - have to tone it down. Terrible instructions - no physical manual, only on CD.
Posted Jun 21, 2005 - I was eying the wonderful LCD ever since Dell made the announcement in March 2005. It was initially introduced with coupons that brought the $1200 MSRP down to $899. I missed out on that, but decided the next time the price dips that low, I am taking the plunge. After taxes, my final price came in just under $1k. That is an amazing price if you consider what the competition sells their similar spec product for.
Right out of the box, the physical set up instructions are simple and easy to follow with the included flow chart (mounting it on the included stand, attaching the appropriate cables, etc). But once you turn on you computer, things get complicated. First, there is no physical manual - it is electronic-HTML based and on the CD. Second, the autorun feature on the CD did not work (gave me error messages), so I had to futz around on the CD to find the necessary instructions on how to lower the brightness. Third, unlike what the ReadMe.txt says (mentions some 2405FPW.inf file that is NOT on the CD or available for download on Dell's website), there is no specific driver for the monitor, you have to use the ones that come with your graphics card.
And here is where another problem crops up. I am not sure whether it is lack of specific drivers for the LCD or the nature of the DVI interface, but most of the adjustments mentioned in the electronic manual cannot be done. And that includes the brightness adjustment, contrast and gamma. They show up when you bring up the OSD, but they are grayed out and inaccessible. I have to make adjustments through the graphics card drivers, and problem is that they are not global - I have to make application specific changes - which can get to be a pain. So for each game I play, I have to adjust the monitor brightness yet again. But that is a minor quibble for somebody like me - who is mainly using this for games and watching movies.
May be that is the nature of DVI - I don't know. This is my first monitor to use DVI. By the way, do not bother using this monitor on anything less then a pure digital interface. While there is VGA port in the back, hooking up you computer to this monitor via VGA will guarantee you an awful image at 1920 x 1200 resolution. The price of using this quality monitor is a requirement for a quality graphics card.
For graphics professionals, having access to and ability to adjust display features is more important and you must make sure your graphics card is compatible. The 1920 x 1200 resolution does require an upper-end card with lots of memory. I have an ATI 9800 Pro with 128 MB, and it is more than adequate (for now). You can go lower if you are mainly using the 2D environment, but for games, you want something more powerful if you want to play at the native resolution of 1920 by 1200. Fortunately for the upper end games that require more power, you can set the LCD to display at the specified resolution, with the surrounding areas blacked out - that way the image does not look bad. If you plan to play the latest games, you will need a beast of a graphics card. I have played Guild Wars, Psychonauts, and Unreal Tournament 2004 at the native 1920 x 1200 resolution without any problems (I did have to tone down the details in Guild Wars for a smooth frame rate). But games like Doom 3, Half Life 2 - my 9800 Pro just will not cut it.
As for image quality itself, the monitor is absolutely beautiful! Once you are satisfied with the adjustments, you will not look at a prettier picture on you computer from another monitor. This is the best monitor out there for computers, regardless of price. I have seen competing products from ViewSonic, Sony and the Apple Cinema displays, and I still think the Dell beats them hands down, at almost half the price!
I always used to get headaches after just an hour sitting in front of a CRT monitor, but never LCDs. The Dell 2405 replaces a 19" Sony Trinitron flat screen CRT and I am glad to have made the switch! The good thing about LCDs compared to CRTs is that the geomtry is perfect everytime, all the time. You never have to make any adjustments. Unlike with my CRT, where it never quite looked right at the edges, no matter how many adjustments - either there was a curve at the top or at the bottom, or at the left side or right side. One side always had some curve.
Bottom line, this is a great monitor, once you have made the necessary adjustments to your liking. At the $899 price point, and all the other features that competitors do not offer - HDTV resolution, 9-in-1 card reader, 4 USB 2.0 ports, multiple connections options, portrait and landscape modes, view angle and height adjustments - makes this monitor a tremendous value. Just be forewarned that once you switch, you will not like going back to anything less.
89% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful , unhelpful, or inappropriate?
Comments - Post a comment