Strengths:SUPER QUIET, REALLY FAST, ZERO-VIBRATION, 8MB Cache, 7200RPM, Lots of space, The Best Hard Drive
Weaknesses:I have hated Western Digital Drives ever since, cause I owned 3 WD Caviars (2GB, 4GB, and 6GB) they all failed on me.
Posted Nov 19, 2002 - I just gave this drive a try, cause I have been hearing very excellent reviews about it. Bought it for $172 at www.essencompu.com, and, geeeeez this is the best drive I have ever owned. Before this, I bought 2 Maxtor 6L080L4, and they were noisy, even having the FDB motors, but the WD1200JB drive is sooo quiet, i cannot hear it working actually. That's what I expected from my maxtors, but they're not. I did not see the improvements also of using ATA133 on those maxtors, but on these WD drives, even using ATA100, i have seen the difference. It is really faster in performance. I have turned on my computer, while holding the drive and did not even hear it or felt it vibrating or something, unlike my Maxtor 80GB, it clunked and clunked and clunked and vibrated... I have been a Maxtor fan for a long time, and if WD makes better drives now (unlike my old drives) I would highly recommend WD's. I have to wait for my drive to last.
Now, Maxtor have released their 8MB Cache drives too, and I am still waiting for it to mature before deciding on my second hard drive purchase, would it be a Maxtor or WD 120GB 8MB Cache? The diff on these drives are the ATA, where the Maxtor uses ATA133 and the WD uses ATA100. On Paper, of course, the Maxtor would perform better given the same Cache size and better ATA133, but its possible noise makes me think twice. I need to find more reviews of the new Maxtors before making any decision.
Go for this WD's, you will not be disappointed.
100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful , unhelpful, or inappropriate?